Originally Posted by
MikePal
I have years of practical first hand knowledge that trumps an internet article :)
I've hunted with a large gang (10-14) hunters for over 20 yrs. Most of that was with dogs and doing a lot of dogging. We had guys successful use buckshot to kill deer almost ever year...it was the gun/ammo of choice and the proper tool of choice for a dogger pushing a bush. The OP was right to question it's effectiveness and as many have said, from their own experiences, that when used within the range limitations it works fine.
As for shoulder shots...we had a couple of guys that use them. I can honestly say I don't remember ever seeing a deer die instantly from one, if it happened it was not the norm.
However most of the deer shot in the shoulder required a second kill shot. Sometimes the trauma was enough that the deer bleed out before the shot was necessary. But inevitably it usually laid there trying to get back up for a spell.
I did not say that the shoulder shot wasn't a kill shot...I said that it NOT a 'Quick' kill shot. It does no one any service to come on a forum and lead people to believe that a shoulder shot is a 'Quick' kill...it's NOT. Not as I have seen in my years of hunting nor have other members who have posted here.