Originally Posted by
Dakota Creek
Am always amazed how owners ... Yes, even retriever owners .... Think their dogs will naturally pick up anything with wings that flies! "I've been training with pigeons and he won't pick up a duck, goose, etc". First question .... Has the dog been exposed to whatever you are expecting the dog to pick up? If the dog has only been trained on bumpers, ducks smell and feel different in their mouths, as do pheasants, and geese different again and talk about a size difference! It takes less time to make the quick introduction of a new species to your dog than to stand there in the field yelling fetch it up while the dog circles around this new "thing" you are asking them to pick up.
To the OP, I would take the time and step back and introduce birds to this dog in a training situation (not just ducks if you are thinking of working him on geese as well). Hopefully you can get him excited about retrieving with hand throwing birds for him to retrieve. Then I would be tempted to add a duck / goose call before sending him for the bird. Then add someone at a greater distance with you calling, and them calling then throwing the bird and sending the dog. At this point if all has gone successfully, I would add a gunshot from the thrower after he calls and throws. If all continues positively, slowly move the gunner closer to where you are running the dog from. Like anyone trying to initially introduce gunfire to a young dog, do not rush this process as you try to discover the anxiety your dog has experienced (gunshots, calls, etc).
You may be asking too much of this dog, particularly if you are expecting to work this dog in colder temperatures (and particularly over water), but wishing you good luck in your training and with your hunting season.