Scotch whiskey recommendations?

I enjoy a glass of nice whiskey on ice once in awhile. Most guys I know just shoot it back, but I’m not much of a fan of this. Sipping and chatting is more my style. I’ve tried many different varieties over the years. My taste buds have settled on Forty creek confederation oak. It’s smooth with no burning after taste. My brother in law is big on scotch. I’ve had it on a few occasions but I think I could breath fire after a glass. Can someone recommend a decent scotch that is smooth and easy drinking?

thanks

Here we go?

I'm a highland scotch guy......the only way to drink scotch is neat or with a couple drops of water.
- Ardmore
- Dalmore
- Aberfeldy........16Yr is you want a real treat

Rye I'm partial to Fourty Creek and for a teat I like Gretzky99 Proof (neat of course)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 410001661

Rye I'm partial to Fourty Creek and for a teat I like Gretzky99 Proof (neat of course)

---

Tried this yet? I'm a fan of Alberta Premium but haven't tried this one yet.

'Alberta Premium Cask Strength' produced by Alberta Distillers, named 'World Whisky of the Year'

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calga...ible-1.5727452

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LowbanksArcher

Tried this yet? I'm a fan of Alberta Premium but haven't tried this one yet.

'Alberta Premium Cask Strength' produced by Alberta Distillers, named 'World Whisky of the Year'

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calga...ible-1.5727452

---

Ya, I saw this.......took a lot of people by surprise. Definitely worth trying out, and is there really such a thing as bad rye? If so that is why god invented Gingerale!!

The beauty of scotch is that not many people like the stuff so you get to keep the whole bottle for yourself.

Cardhu, for me. I visit Scotland, most years, (golf, St Andrews) so if anyone would like a brand only sold in Scotland, ( there are many),let me know and I will bring some back for you. I do it for friends, they let me know their max per bottle, and if they don't know the brand, I find them something the 'locals' drink. No complaints yet. Once a friend put the limit at 200$ for a bottle ,( 20 years ago), wife was a little concerned, that I would not be compensated. Thankfully there was no problem getting paid, and he was happy with my choice. Ps. I know he refilled that bottle more than once........lol.

My favorite Single is Dalwhinnie. https://www.lcbo.com/webapp/wcs/stor...-whisky-238097

Too far up the mountain to have Turf or Peat delivered by Jaunting cart. So they fire with gas. No smokey peat flavor.

Johnny Walker Black Label for me,especially,when it shows up at Christmas under the tree. :thumbup:

GLENFIDDICH
15 Year Old Solera Reserve

Ballantine's Blended Scotch Whisky

Cutty Sark Blended Scotch Blended Whisky

I haven't had a drink in almost 25 years now, but there was a time that Scotch was my favourite beverage.
It's an acquired taste. To me best covering two or three ice cubes, no mix.
Ballantines was what I drank most times. Not the cheapest on the market but far from high end.
If I felt rich I might spring for the Glenfiddich.
The biggest thing I found with most whisky is that before you open the bottle tip it over gently a time or two.
If not, the first drink from the bottle is quite bitter.
Don't get me wrong. I am no expert, nor was I an alcoholic. Just enjoyed a good drink.

T 21, have you tried J.W. Green Label? Is is worth the extra cost. I am not much of a scotch drinker, so whatever I bring back from Scotland ,usually lasts until the next trip. Unless we entertain company ,who will indulge. In Scotland , the old boys, drink it 'neat' with a half pint on the side to alleviate the 'burn'. Water? Cubes? Sacrilege...." what the bloody hell".

Glenmorangie 10 year old is very smooth.

Sent from my SM-A520W using Tapatalk

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TroutSlayer

My favorite Single is Dalwhinnie. https://www.lcbo.com/webapp/wcs/stor...-whisky-238097

Too far up the mountain to have Turf or Peat delivered by Jaunting cart. So they fire with gas. No smokey peat flavor.

---

I agree ... I have a bottle sitting next to me right now at my work desk!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MarkB

I agree ... I have a bottle sitting next to me right now at my work desk!

---

Cheers pal!

I’m going to go broke testing all these suggestions!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

Cardhu, for me. I visit Scotland, most years, (golf, St Andrews) so if anyone would like a brand only sold in Scotland, ( there are many),let me know and I will bring some back for you. I do it for friends, they let me know their max per bottle, and if they don't know the brand, I find them something the 'locals' drink. No complaints yet. Once a friend put the limit at 200$ for a bottle ,( 20 years ago), wife was a little concerned, that I would not be compensated. Thankfully there was no problem getting paid, and he was happy with my choice. Ps. I know he refilled that bottle more than once........lol.

---

Nice....what gold course in St. Andrews did you play? Definitely on my bucket list.

Lagavulin 16. Single Malt Islay. Very Peaty. If you like smoky peaty you will like it. Might not be what you are looking for.

If you want a smooth easy drinking whiskey that's not scotch than my choice is Maker's Mark.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

T 21, have you tried J.W. Green Label? Is is worth the extra cost. I am not much of a scotch drinker, so whatever I bring back from Scotland ,usually lasts until the next trip. Unless we entertain company ,who will indulge. In Scotland , the old boys, drink it 'neat' with a half pint on the side to alleviate the 'burn'. Water? Cubes? Sacrilege...." what the bloody hell".

---

I've seen it,but,never tried it. It takes me about 4 months to get through a bottle of scotch. I tend to keep that to myself. Mrs.T can't stand it.:D Maybe,I'll try some next time. Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sawbill

The beauty of scotch is that not many people like the stuff so you get to keep the whole bottle for yourself.

---

I'd help you drink yours... with coke.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 410001661

Nice....what gold course in St. Andrews did you play? Definitely on my bucket list.

---

I have played them all, some many times. My Father in law was from there. His brother was a caddy on the Old Course. Our family has attended 6 Open Championships including 5 on the Old Course.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Birdbuff

I enjoy a glass of nice whiskey on ice once in awhile. Most guys I know just shoot it back, but I’m not much of a fan of this. Sipping and chatting is more my style. I’ve tried many different varieties over the years. My taste buds have settled on Forty creek confederation oak. It’s smooth with no burning after taste. My brother in law is big on scotch. I’ve had it on a few occasions but I think I could breath fire after a glass. Can someone recommend a decent scotch that is smooth and easy drinking?

thanks

---

There isn't any, besides it's bad for your health...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

I have played them all, some many times. My Father in law was from there. His brother was a caddy on the Old Course. Our family has attended 6 Open Championships including 5 on the Old Course.

---

All 20? I just want one for my bucket list......and to shoot a round of sporting clays there as well.

Aaaaaaaaaaah whiskey ! The water of life. You are entering a world unto itself when it comes to Scotch whiskey. The purist would insist only a singlemalt ( the older the better) to grace his lips but for many a newbie are lost as to where to start. Over 40 years ago my BiL started me off on the cheaper stuff. Ballantine's, Chivas, Cutty Sark, etc., etc.. As he moved me up to singlemalts it taught me to appreciate the subtle differences. A lot of the brands already mentioned are a good place to start . Blends are okay but finding that one special one is your journey . Remember that each distillery brews a product based on it's regions resources and hence each will have a unique flavour. Good luck on your quest as I continue mine.

Old Scottish saying after a wee dram " Like an angel peeing on yer tongue."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Birdbuff

I enjoy a glass of nice whiskey on ice once in awhile. Most guys I know just shoot it back, but I’m not much of a fan of this. Sipping and chatting is more my style. I’ve tried many different varieties over the years. My taste buds have settled on Forty creek confederation oak. It’s smooth with no burning after taste. My brother in law is big on scotch. I’ve had it on a few occasions but I think I could breath fire after a glass. Can someone recommend a decent scotch that is smooth and easy drinking?

thanks

---

I don't mind a scotch-whiskey blend but I'm a big fan of the islays, myself.
Liquid gold, especially in the cold, long winter nights: https://www.lcbo.com/webapp/wcs/stor...oductId=257050

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 410001661

All 20? I just want one for my bucket list......and to shoot a round of sporting clays there as well.

---

Don't know where you got the 20 courses from. There are 7 courses in the St. Andrews links trust plus The Dukes course that is not a links course. The courses are owned by the town of St. Andrews. Yes I have played them all. There are so many great Scottish courses within 50 miles of St Andrews and I have played most of them as well. ( Carnoustie, Kings Barns, Lundin Links, Crail, Balcomie , Muirfield, Scots Craig ).. The clay shooting you are looking for, is across the Eden estuary, closer to Tentsmuir. I watched the try outs for the Scottish National team there once. Those guys don't miss many. Only 98 out of 100 will get you bounced.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

Don't know where you got the 20 courses from. There are 7 courses in the St. Andrews links trust plus The Dukes course that is not a links course. The courses are owned by the town of St. Andrews. Yes I have played them all. There are so many great Scottish courses within 50 miles of St Andrews and I have played most of them as well. ( Carnoustie, Kings Barns, Lundin Links, Crail, Balcomie , Muirfield, Scots Craig ).. The clay shooting you are looking for, is across the Eden estuary, closer to Tentsmuir. I watched the try outs for the Scottish National team there once. Those guys don't miss many. Only 98 out of 100 will get you bounced.

---

Funny story... we went to Scotland for our honeymoon in 2002. We drove town to town and stayed in B&B's. I spent much of one day looking around St. Andrew's for a course that had clubs for "hire" so I could play a round. Finally a fellow at a nearby course asked "why don't you just go over to St. Andrew's, they have 7 courses and lots of equipment to hire". I had just assumed I'd never be able to get a tee time.

I ended up playing the Eden course that afternoon, missed out on playing the Old Course by an hour or so.

The thing that surprised me most about St. Andrew's is you can walk the grounds all day without paying a cent. It was weird to see at first, but it's normal to see people just strolling along the fairways. As you say, it's part of the town.

Sent from my SM-A520W using Tapatalk

If you ever have the ability to go to St. Andrews , do it. If you are a golfer , it truly is a magical place. I have seen grown men weeping on the first tee, at the majesty of it all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sawbill

The beauty of scotch is that not many people like the stuff so you get to keep the whole bottle for yourself.

---

My 20 yr old has developed a taste for single malt much to my dismay. He will be buying the next couple of bottles here...
Dalwhinnie, Highland Park Magnus or the Highland Park 12yr old are what we are drinking these days

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

If you ever have the ability to go to St. Andrews , do it. If you are a golfer , it truly is a magical place. I have seen grown men weeping on the first tee, at the majesty of it all.

---

I love golf, but the only way I will be weeping on the first tee is if I shanked my first drive.......dooooh

For many golfers it is a life long dream. A pilgrimage if you will. Many take a piece of the sod home.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fishermccann

If you ever have the ability to go to St. Andrews , do it. If you are a golfer , it truly is a magical place. I have seen grown men weeping on the first tee, at the majesty of it all.

---

I've seen grown men weeping at a pitch and putt, after they lost their 15th ball... LOL.

Balvenie, although 18 year old Glenfiddich was brought to the camp one year, it was a good dual between the 2 of them.