Hey everyone! I'm looking to learn to fish this year and I was wondering how you know the fish is safe to eat. I know there is the "Guide to Eating Ontario Fish", but what about areas that don't have recommendations? What do you guys do?
Thanks!
Printable View
Hey everyone! I'm looking to learn to fish this year and I was wondering how you know the fish is safe to eat. I know there is the "Guide to Eating Ontario Fish", but what about areas that don't have recommendations? What do you guys do?
Thanks!
Eat my fish and forget the guidelines
All caught from small lakes, by the time you’ll eat enough to hurt yourself you’ll be sick of fish
Keep the the medium size and let the bigger ones go.
Sent from my SM-G975W using Tapatalk
Short of referencing the guide there is nothing conclusive.
Some considerations that can be made is 1. younger fish over older fish.
2. prey fish over predator fish
3. Occasional meals over every meal
4. fillets with as much of the brown fat removed over whole baked fish
Or just close your eyes and enjoy a meal of fresh caught fish
Also avoid species that are notoriously high for contaminants. Usually species that are high fat, long-lived (longer period for bioaccumulation) , and primarily eat fish ( piscivorous ) as their forage. Fish like lake trout, salmon, burbot, channel catfish will consistently rank much higher for contaminants. In many water bodies these species will not be safe to eat, period, especially if they are larger fish eg. something like a 16 pound channel cat from below the Dunnville dam would be basically hazardous waste! . Some regions of the province will be high for contaminants due mainly to geological features eg. the clay belt region in New Liskeard to Cochrane area. Clay is a chelating agent for methyl mercury (increases availability and uptake in the foodchain). Many lakes in this area will tend to have "no consumption" levels of contaminants (mainly methyl mercury if it goes about .5ppm if I remember correctly) unless you are sticking to very small fish.. Check the guidelines before you book a $4000 fly-in fishing trip in God's Country if you plan to be eating what you catch. Many remote northern waterbodies (especially if they are impounded systems) will have high to very high mercury levels.
I always check the consumption guide to be safe. I personally avoid anything from the great lakes. Be aware of the Lake Superior zero consumption rules for rainbow smelt, and assume it's the same for the remaining great lakes since the MOEE doesn't test these other lakes for the class of contaminants that have caused the Superior guidelines
Ya, to clarify my fish I eat are all caught from small lakes in central Ontario, we don’t have salmon or steal head which can be high in mercury. The most common fish we eat are 15-16 inch walleye, 20 inch pike, 2-3 pound bass, 10-12 inch brook trout, and lot’s of jumbo perch and bluegills. I believe the guidelines would say for most of these species to eat no more than two meals a week. We generally eat fish about once to twice a week in the summer and have had no issues.
Welcome aboard. If you think about mercury content,just push the fish headfirst into a snowbank. When the mercury drops,cut the head off. End of problem. Bon appetite!Quote:
Originally Posted by macaw
Fillet the fish, and remove fats, and dont feed to fast growing infants and pregnant women.
ull be fine with 1 feeding a week.
been eating lake ontario salmon for a long time. havent grown 4th hand, just the regular 3 hands ... lol
We simply dont know if its better or worse than farmed fish from grocery store.
been reading about micro plastic making its way to fish muscle also, something thats not monitored or measured even. so im not sure if a bit of mercury is our biggest worry at this point.
Same here
Quote:
Originally Posted by hunter06
I've seen a few people mention to avoid salmon, steelhead, and lake trout. Would brook trout fall under the same category? Thanks
When I started looking into the safety I realized even the store bought stuff has it's issues too. I heard that the farmed stuff uses an additive to make salmon, and I assume any other pink fish look pink.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ata83
That's true about the microplastics too, I didn't think of that.
I've toured the fish pens of rainbow trout up in the north channel. The buyer (say Dominion) would come up to inspect the pens they were to purchase. The seller (farm operator) would bring out a book of pictures and ask the buyer "which photo looks like what you want your fillets to look like under glass and lights in the store?". The seller would then adjust the red dye number 7 added to the food pellets for the next few weeks. When the fish were ready for market, they looked just like the picture buddy picked. It's true!Quote:
Originally Posted by macaw
I'll take a wild speck that's been eating hellgrammites and stonefly nymphs any day. Natural orange tasty flesh. :)
Is there any areas would you avoid? As in creeks near the city? Or maybe other red flags for you?Quote:
Originally Posted by TroutSlayer;[URL="tel:1210258"
Just privite property.Quote:
Originally Posted by macaw
Brook trout are better, because they do not feed on as many small fish as stealhead or salmon, which translates to lower mercury levels. I will say I have eaten a few freshly caught winter and spring run stealhead. Those are some tasty fish especially the smaller ones.