Upland Dog For an Old Fat Dude

[trky chsr]

Ok I'm not really fat but I am slowing down a bit. I asked for advice on here about a Springer and I got some really good leads, thanks. I really like Springers but I'm not sure if I can still keep up with one. I want to hunt with my dog not chase it all over the woods. I know you can train them to hunt close but it's really tough ( I've owned Springers for over 30 years). So are there any other breeds that work slower and closer? Another fellow I know who is in the same boat is thinking about a Brittany. Being a pointer they would be a lot easier to keep up with ( at least when they find the birds). Any thoughts? TC

[CCR]

Have you looked into a Clumber or Sussex Spaniel?

[trkyhntr21]

If you can't keep up with a spainel and haven't been successful with training one to work within gun range. You probably aren't going to fair well with a pointing breed.

[trky chsr]

If you can't keep up with a spainel and haven't been successful with training one to work within gun range. You probably aren't going to fair well with a pointing breed.

Oh I've trained my Springers to work within gun range but they are still really just high energy dogs even at home as pets. From people I've talked to about Brittany's they aren't quite as strung out as say an English pointer.

[trky chsr]

Have you looked into a Clumber or Sussex Spaniel?

I haven't found anyone who owns one and I haven't researched them either. I know someone who raises Welsh Springers and they may suit my needs. Nothing personal but every Cocker I've know has been a little hole so I'm not really interested in one of those either.

[finsfurfeathers]

Guess the breed you might be looking for is a Spinone. Honestly though I think you are looking for a particular dog rather than breed. Within every breed you'll find difference in temperament even between siblings.
I have setters and I like the dog to chase me not the other way around. I've picked a pup with the temperament to hunt with me. Is this what the experts say, no but for me I like to see my dog.
Your best bet would probably be a started dog which will give you the best idea how bidable it will be.

[thunderbelly]

"Your best bet would probably be a started dog which will give you the best idea how bidable it will be. " awesome advice.
Sometimes you can find a retired/ retiring stud dog that the breeder is willing to part with.

[trky chsr]

Guess the breed you might be looking for is a Spinone. Honestly though I think you are looking for a particular dog rather than breed. Within every breed you'll find difference in temperament even between siblings.
I have setters and I like the dog to chase me not the other way around. I've picked a pup with the temperament to hunt with me. Is this what the experts say, no but for me I like to see my dog.
Your best bet would probably be a started dog which will give you the best idea how bidable it will be.

Good advice, that's something I'll have to look at.

[trkyhntr21]

Brittany's are more then capable of running off and self hunting as is any other pointing breed.
Structure and training goes a long way as does the right dog.
Yes I have pointers and they aren't suited for everybody.I have to check for a pulse when they are in the house. They also handle in the grouse woods. And turn it on and take huge casts in Texas.
The point being is Training is something that is the highest priority regardless of breed.
Buying a started or trained dog is a great idea but you have to keep them that way.


Sent from my SM-G955W using Tapatalk

[terrym]

I have a Brittany. Not a good choice if you're looking for a slow close working dog. I know people who run Vislas and they are slower closer working dogs. Breeding makes a big difference though. Avoid field trial bloodlines as they tend to be bigger runners.