-
January 6th, 2020, 05:31 PM
#11
Anyone ever had ministry go ahead to "protect livestock"?
Living on a farm all my life and having calves/pets killed by coyotes not once have I ever had the go ahead from ministry, OFA, County or any other assoc. I hunt at big sheep farms too that have sheep killed by coyotes. Farmer might get compensation threw insurance eventually, But neither him or I would get anything from killing a coyote over the deadstock.
I have shot coyotes on farms over dead stock, Called about compensation and they ask if I can prove THIS coyote killed THIS calf. They will want the coyote for testing. Just a bunch of run around so they dont have to pay out.
And I would like to see ANY CO give you the go ahead to let pelts spoil. I know any CO I have seen when I'm coyote hunting always tells me I better be making use of the pelt.
Sent from my SM-G960W using Tapatalk
"If guns cause crime, all of mine are defective."
-Ted Nugent
-
January 6th, 2020 05:31 PM
# ADS
-
January 6th, 2020, 09:15 PM
#12
The livestock insurance claims are run through your township/municipality. Have put in numerous claims through out the years and they have always been honoured. Usually a township/municipal employee who does the investigation. They show up, look at the remains take some pictures. I usually give them a copy of a old receipt of the livestock in question. IE had a turkey killed by coyotes, gave him a receipt for what I sell my turkeys for and a month later had a check for the loss of my turkey.
As far as I know they will never cover the cost of you hiring an “Agent” to remove wildlife. I have been an “Agent” numerous times and always stress that I need to remove the animal at the scene of the crime so to speak.
For example if I shoot two coyotes in the summer that have been coming into a farmyard during calving season, the pelts have no value and dump them. If I shoot a bear that is coming in during the same time, you can bet I have pictures of it on more then one occasion, with written statements by the landowners showing damage done and I contact the ministry to discuss the situation before acting on the landowners behalf.
I have never run into a problem. I have had to turn over animals to the ministry over the years, which is fine. Sometimes they want it for testing. Sometimes they don’t say but want to make sure I do not have it or the landowner does not.
Song dog is correct that not once has the ministry offered to remove an animal that was causing issues. Maybe they would act if there was a rabid fox etc. But for farmers losing stock it’s usually the old 12 gauge and the manure pile.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
January 7th, 2020, 09:40 AM
#13

Originally Posted by
trimmer21
This doesn't make sense. Calling is an acceptable method. Why would anyone be going to court?
For allowing the pelt of a furbearing mammal to spoil. You can only allow the pelt to spoil if you are protecting your property from wildlife that "is damaging or is about to damage" it. A coyote running in looking for a screaming rabbit is not there to damage your property.

Originally Posted by
SongDog
Anyone ever had ministry go ahead to "protect livestock"?
I've never had an MNR official tell me that it is okay to protect my livestock.
I've also never had an MTO official tell me that it is okay for me to drive to work. The law says I can do it, so I do.
If they think I'm breaking the law it is their job to prove it in court. Some folks think that you could prove that calling in animals is protecting livestock. Many at the MNRF disagree. The actual decision on whether a law has been broken is made by a Justice of the Peace.
-
January 7th, 2020, 03:32 PM
#14
[QUOTE=benjhind;1101842]For allowing the pelt of a furbearing mammal to spoil. You can only allow the pelt to spoil if you are protecting your property from wildlife that "is damaging or is about to damage" it. A coyote running in looking for a screaming rabbit is not there to damage your property.
I've never had an MNR official tell me that it is okay to protect my livestock.
I've also never had an MTO official tell me that it is okay for me to drive to work. The law says I can do it, so I do.
If they think I'm breaking the law it is their job to prove it in court. Some folks think that you could prove that calling in animals is protecting livestock. Many at the MNRF disagree. The actual decision on whether a law has been broken is made by a Justice of the Peace.[
As a yote hunter or acting agent at what point does a predator become wildlife " that is damaging or about to damage" property? And how would I know that. This reminds me of giving our yotes to a trapper that said " just bring me the yotes that are worth more $100.
I should add the reason I am asking we were asked by a horse farmer to shoot yotes that were eating his cats. We set up a caller within a 100 yards of the barn and sat next to the barn. Ist time out we shot 2 yotes and next time shot 2 out of 3 using a screaming rabbit call?
Last edited by tracker; January 7th, 2020 at 03:49 PM.
Experience is what you gain when you didn't get what you wanted.
Many are called but only a few are chosen.
-
January 7th, 2020, 03:57 PM
#15
I'd call that hunting, but have a chat with your local CO about their interpretation.
A bear ripping into your beehives, a coyote chasing your dog, a coon in your chicken coop... these are all examples of wildlife that is damaging or about to damage your property.
Just because a species eats meat doesn't give you carte blanche to wipe them off the face of the province.
Think about the bears and bees example. Imagine if every beekeeper killed a couple dozen bears a year and let them rot in the bush. Or if every trapper harvested way over their quota of fisher or lynx because one time their cat disappeared.
Again, I'm not your CO. Their interpretation is more important than mine.
-
January 7th, 2020, 04:13 PM
#16
U should watch a you tube clip where a yote in a Ohio cemetery is watching a older women walking her dog on the sidewalk and see the yote stalking her.
The cat eating was not a one time event, the yotes were coming into the yard daily. He could give us the time of the day. He lost more than one cat and still losing cats. Have you ever hunted yotes, not by calling but pushing on foot to actually see how they behave and have changed. I hope you or any other hunter would not be hunting in a barnyard.
Experience is what you gain when you didn't get what you wanted.
Many are called but only a few are chosen.
-
January 7th, 2020, 04:13 PM
#17

Originally Posted by
benjhind
Think about the bears and bees example. Imagine if every beekeeper killed a couple dozen bears a year and let them rot in the bush.
Couple dozen bear HaHa...a least try to be realistic.
With over $500 invested in equipment and potential of $500 to $1000+ worth of honey...the loss to a bear attack is substantial. So yes nuisance bears are considered fair game.
Should add..my wife is a beekeeper and is a member of the Eastern Ontario Beekeepers Association (large group). While some have loses to bears , never heard of any having killed a bear. Doesn't happen often.
and if it happens here...it will find it's afterlife in my freezer.
Last edited by MikePal; January 7th, 2020 at 04:22 PM.
-
January 7th, 2020, 04:28 PM
#18
I have been hunting yotes in our area since the 1970 when they first showed up. Back than we had jackrabbits and foxes. No yotes. We have yet to be denied land to hunt yotes and this includes houses in the country. You will never kill all the yotes and I hate to admit it our group and every other yote hunter in our area is not doing a good job.
Experience is what you gain when you didn't get what you wanted.
Many are called but only a few are chosen.
-
January 7th, 2020, 04:52 PM
#19

Originally Posted by
tracker
You will never kill all the yotes and I hate to admit it our group and every other yote hunter in our area is not doing a good job.
The vast majority of yotes I've shot were in the barnyard...shot while I was in my slippers from the front porch or back deck. I've only shot a couple while out hunting over the past years and for all the track I've seen, you'd think you'd see more of them while in a stand hunting. They are very elusive.
The only real successfull groups around here use dogs and run them.
-
January 7th, 2020, 05:06 PM
#20

Originally Posted by
tracker
U should watch a you tube clip where a yote in a Ohio cemetery is watching a older women walking her dog on the sidewalk and see the yote stalking her.
The cat eating was not a one time event, the yotes were coming into the yard daily. He could give us the time of the day. He lost more than one cat and still losing cats. Have you ever hunted yotes, not by calling but pushing on foot to actually see how they behave and have changed. I hope you or any other hunter would not be hunting in a barnyard.
I'm not sure what an old lady in a graveyard has to do with protecting property. Unless you happen to own a bunch of old ladies?
Why shouldn't I hunt in a barnyard? I have hunted many. All my best pigeon hunts have been in barnyards. I used to get the odd rabbit in the long grass in front of my dad's barn when I was a kid.