Just don't command your dog to flush at the trial, whats the problem?
Printable View
Just don't command your dog to flush at the trial, whats the problem?
Good to know. I was just going on what I saw in the videos posted - the hunter did an awful lot of walking around before actually lifting a bird. I don't think either type (flusher or pointer) is superior over the other, a good nose is a good nose. I appreciate good dog work regardless of the method.Quote:
Originally Posted by finsfurfeathers
The flushing is not the problem.Quote:
Originally Posted by Winchey
"In a field trial , the dog won't flush unless given the command, which won't happen in a field trial - must be steady to flush and shot , but will relocate , if used to doing that when needed which equals a disqualification." quote Sh
As I said the flushing is not the problem ; the relocating is. Once the dog gets used to relocating on its own when hunting, waiting to be sent to relocate by the handler in a trial is a challenge for the dog.
If your dog is trained it isn't a challenge.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharon
Relocating in a trial is only a problem if the handler has whoa'd the dog or the handler is making a flushing attempt. A self relocation during either of those circumstances will end your run. I allow my dogs to self relocate in trials, it avoids unproductive points and allows them to pin running birds if it takes a few minutes to get to them. The biggest mistake most handlers make is they whoa their dogs as soon as the dog stops and commit the dog to standing still until released. I allow my dogs to break on their own until I get in front of them and start flushing, then they know they need to stand there. If you never let your dogs self relocate they will never learn how to hunt and distinguish between "the bird is there" and "the bird was there". If my dogs stop and I get in front of them there needs to be a bird there. It is all part of the training process and it requires a lot of wild bird contacts.
Making a pointer flush on command is easy but you better fully break him first or he will start busting birds on you before you get there. If I was going to do that I wouldn't let it flush every bird I would do some myself just to keep the dog guessing.
Cass, this isn't a slam on flusher's because you guys can get birds too, but the pointing dogs will find birds that the flusher's won't just due to the difference in ranges. A flusher's hunting range I imagine is inside 40 yds, the range of my pointers, when hunting, is up to 150 yds. When the grouse are scarce the pointers will find more birds just due to the extra ground they cover.
good point I forgot : the dog can relocate in a trial if you haven't whoa'd the dog or got in front for a flushing attempt.
so true:
"The biggest mistake most handlers make is they whoa their dogs as soon as the dog stops and commit the dog to standing still until released." quote Jakezilla
That is exactly right. I allow my dogs to relocate on their own as well. Nothing worse then beating brush for 150 yards to a point, only to find the bird ran away and is long gone. Until I have started my flush it is between the bird and the dog.
I have also been lazy a few times and didn't want to flush in some sort of rats nest or blow down or something and have had the dogs do it. Just makes it a little more difficult to keep them broke doing that all the time.
Perhaps Cass or other flusher owners can chime in with some advice...Quote:
Originally Posted by Cass
I'm on my first bird dog, a lab, which works close when I want it to; generally about 10 yards in grouse & woodcock cover. But she picks up scent a long way off, and when she gets birdy I've got to move FAST to ensure I'm in a position to shoot when she charges in. I'm not finding much time at all to get ready.
If she scents it far off would that not give you more time? If you need more time to get in position, hit the stop whistle when you see her get birdy. Then release her to flush. Does she sit to the flush?
Awesome!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharon
The obvious factor in a trial is that if your dog self relocates, it can't bump the bird in that effort! I guess that's stating the obvious... :) Even if I'm hunting my pointer and it flushes on a relocate, I will not shoot at that bird. It is unacceptable to me personally - not the self-relocate, the flush is though.
There is no "better" breed. A good flusher is better than a poor pointer and vice versa.
We all have our preferences however I'm grateful to have had the pleasure of having hunted over wonderful dogs from both sides of the house. A good dog is something to behold. It's the same reason that I look for a gun that contributes to my hunting experience rather than one that simply goes "Boom" or should I say, "Boomboomboom" when you pull the trigger.